(2005 movie)
This is a film that's received a lot of praise in some circles because it's seen as being different from the standard horror flick. I can't say I really agree all with that, and I'll explain why soon enough. First, though, I have to put the disclaimer out there that I'm not really a horror movie fan, though I do watch some of them if they sound interesting. The Descent sounded like it might be one of those movies, but in the end I didn't care for it because it still had pretty much all the same clichés that I don't like about horror movies, chief among them stupid characters. The thing is, when a movie is filled with stupid people, I find that I can't really sympathize with them all that much, so I don't care what happens to them. If they're really bad, I actually start to cheer for whatever or whoever is hunting them down. The Descent avoided the latter, but not the former. Instead, it was safely in "meh" territory, much like Pandorum. One thing that does separate it from Pandorum, though, is that it takes its sweet time instead of diving right in, in an attempt to make us feel sorry for the characters, I guess.
It's been said that this movie represents female empowerment somehow, and that it avoids the typical romantic subplots that most horror movies have. The same people who say that kind of thing also criticize most horror movies for basically boiling down to "monster chases attractive female character," and naturally the implication there is that this movie somehow avoids that. But really, it doesn't. In fact, the only movie I've seen that avoids both the romantic subplot and "monster chases attractive female character" storyline is The Thing. Actually, I bring this up because this movie is often compared to it specifically for that reason, the specious claim being that the only difference here is that the cast is all female rather than male. Unfortunately for these reviewers, they've forgotten a rather important element from the start of the movie that comes into play at the end of the movie – an affair between the protagonist's husband and one of her friends. Because while this friend, Juno, is later made out to be the antagonist for the group for several reasons, really what it comes down to for me is that the main character, Sarah, ends up taking revenge on her not for any of those reasons, but really for the affair with her husband right before her family was destroyed.
You see, right in the beginning of the movie, we're introduced to Sarah, Juno, and Beth, another of their friends, along with Sarah's husband and young daughter. Sarah and her friends like doing extreme sports, and in this case they're white water rafting while the husband and kid watch from shore. When the women are done and meet up with Sarah's husband and kid on shore, it becomes really painfully obvious that Sarah's husband has developed a case of yellow fever (Juno is played by an Asian actress in case you didn't get that

So, fast-forward to a year later, and Sarah is meeting up with all of her friends in the good ol' US of A to do some spelunking. We're introduced to three more characters, but they aren't really all that important, so I'll only mention Holly. Why? Well, just look:

*sigh* So kawaii...

Now the movie takes a decent amount of time establishing the friendship between these women and their hobby for extreme sports, of which caving is only one of them, apparently. This is both good and bad because it gives the audience information, but in the end it failed to really make me feel anything for these characters one way or another when it came to their little cave adventure. Then not long after this, some of the characters, namely Juno and Holly, start to develop personalities that start to wear on me very quickly. Holly in particular becomes rude, mouthy, and overconfident, so it should be unsurprising that she's the first to die. What might be surprising is that it takes about and hour into the movie for this to happen.
Anyway, the basic plot of the movie is actually pretty similar to The Cave, which came out the same year. Basically, a group of people wanders down into an unknown cave and gets picked off by the mutant human cave dwellers after getting cut off from the only known exit. The main differences aside from tone are that there's a larger team of mixed races and sexes and that the creatures are more like bats, which can both fly and swim. In The Descent, the creatures look like Morlocks from The Time Machine.

Juno planned this adventure that would get most of them killed as a way of making up to Sarah, as she explains later. The problem was that Juno took them to an unexplored cave and lied about it, telling them that instead they were going to a well-explored one. The thing is, this makes no sense, because most of the women are pretty new to the whole caving thing, and Sarah in particular has a thing with closed in spaces. Oh, and Juno never told anyone where they were going. Convenient. This is pretty painfully obvious to me as a way of making Juno out to be the antagonist of the group, even while the movie at the same time makes her out to be someone who fights to save her friends. The thing that's supposed to seal it later on is when, after fighting really hard and losing against the Morlocks to keep them from dragging off Holly's body, Beth, for some unknown reason, quietly sneaks up behind Juno right after she's finished killing one of the monsters and gets a pick-axe to the neck. Now Juno really obviously didn't intend to kill Beth, but really the only bad thing she did was to freak out and run off instead of looking after her. But the movie insists that this is an unforgivable sin, like Juno meant to kill Beth, so in spite of all the fighting Juno does to try to save her friends, including the body of one who was already dead, this is all basically so Sarah has an excuse to kill her. And while the movie reasons that this is for revenge over Beth and leading them all down there, it was fairly transparent for me that it was more about the affair from the beginning of the movie, and this is actually brought up toward the end of the movie. So really it doesn't avoid the romance subplot at all, it just shoves it more into the background than usual. It also doesn't avoid the "monsters chasing attractive female characters" plot in the least, so the only thing really of note here is that during the main storyline in the cave there are no male characters for any of the women to fawn over.
The movie isn't all bad, though, as cliché-filled as it is. It actually does have one point toward female empowerment in that the women don't freak out so much as to be completely useless even though there are things trying to kill them, and they even fight back. That was actually kind of refreshing because the usual response to "monster chases attractive female character" is for said character to shriek and run away whilst acting stupidly and not even attempting to fight back. It also didn't overcompensate by having the women be completely bad ass either, so they characters themselves were fairly well-rounded and believable. I'll also give this movie a point for managing to successfully gross me out without resorting to gore porn. Instead, it reminded me of seeing animals get eaten, only with Holly being the one getting eaten by these cave dwellers. And while normally I might crack a joke here about a woman getting eaten out, I have to say that the way the body and head moved combined with the hyena calls made it so I just couldn't bring myself to do it.
But that's pretty much it on the positive side. Everything else is either neutral or bad as far as I'm concerned. They even do the thing with making the characters crawl through gross stuff and let the monsters crawl over them without them getting noticed that so many movies have done on more than one occasion, not to mention the fake happy ending where the main character seems to make it only for it to turn out to be a dream or delusion. The only thing that makes it worse is the sequel, which implies that despite overwhelming odds, both Juno and Sarah survived long enough to be in the sequel. But since it wasn't obvious that this movie was going to have a sequel I guess I can't really dock it for that, but that won't stop me when it comes time to rate the sequel. Instead, this ending was somewhat ambiguous, though it was definitely leaning toward "everyone dies," which isn't the usual, but isn't all that unique either.
Overall I found this movie to be fairly average; definitely not deserving of the majority of the praise that's been heaped upon it by some. Like Pandorum, it wasn't really especially bad, though it did have plenty of eye-roll worthy moments and the same kind of leaps in logic. I still think that The Thing, The Mist and Alien are the best horror movies I've ever seen because they're just good movies by themselves, so it is still damning with faint praise to say that The Descent was probably okay as far as horror movies go. Keep in mind that most horror movies involve stupid people doing stupid things until they're killed as far as I'm concerned. So with that, I'd rate this movie a 5/10.