I also didn't find Trip particularly appealing until his personality won me over. Well, that and his great arms. But since "Home" is what dragged me into the series for real, apparently I like him best when I can see him really suffering.
I really don't think Bakula is served by the very short hair. To me it just emphasizes a certain primate quality. But I think he has a very appealing physique.
Probably the guy I found most handsome right out of the gate in any ST series was Chakotay, though I could have done without the facial tattoo. Bashir was a hottie too, though I don't think his personality appealed to me very much. Spock and Scotty in TOS were early objects of affection, but Spock was the one I really went ga-ga over. I guess I go for tall-ish, dark, handsome/interesting, and at least a bit tortured.
Which might explain my husband.
